Oh hey, how about a Christmas post 2 weeks late? Well, if you insist!
For the most part our Christmas was entirely predictable – gifts, sugar, music, last minute crafts, messes, and lots of excited screaming.
The thing that we changed this year was Santa. Now, I know it is a heated topic of debate in the parenting world, this Santa thing. And honestly, Tom and I straddle the fence. We are not religious, so we don’t feel like we are taking anything away from “the true meaning of Christmas”, but we also are not entirely comfortable with the cultural attitudes around Santa, and the holiday in general. We strive to live simply, and an entire holiday based on consumption is a hard thing to juggle when the mascot for the holiday brings you everything you ask for because you have somehow earned it with good behavior. We love the magic of the holiday, but wish it could be more focused on celebrating our family and community than anticipating the gift grab. In the absence of a religious tradition, it seems even more important that we to create traditions in our family that shift the focus.
Which brings us to Santa. In the past, our tactic has been along the lines of treating him like all the other magic our kids believe in. We play along with their games, and when they ask if something is real, we ask “Well, what do you think?” Ella is our believer, Alice our skeptic. (Becky just wants to be part of the game, so she’ll agree to anything.) We talked a lot about how Santa was the spirit of giving, how we had a bit of Santa in us as well, and how the guy at the mall was just for fun, etc. And in years past this worked.
This year, Santa took on a different tenor, probably a direct effect of the hours of Christmas movies the girls watched on Netflix this year because I have been couch bound. Somehow Santa had morphed from magic, to reality, and a reality which would be bringing them a room full of new toys. This was immediately after their birthday party, when they had more new toys to play with than they could keep track of, yet somehow the gifts Santa was bringing made these gifts seem paltry. They saw not one, but TWO mall Santas this year thanks to Grandma, and each had a list of toys he had promised them. And I knew it had to stop.
I came up with the plan when Tom and I were looking into charities we wanted to donate to this year. We give to charity because we like to. We certainly do not need the tax break, and we are not giving enough to have our names listed on the plaque in the hall, but we give because we are blessed to have a warm home, a full freezer, and a community that won’t let us starve if worse came to worse. And until now, the girls have not been very involved in this process.
Again, without a religious tradition it it hard to find ways to discuss hardship, illness and poverty without scaring them. If we could practice the act of prayer I would be much less worried - the comfort found in giving these anxieties up to someone who can control them can be huge, but is not one we can currently teach out children. We try to be honest, to give them a vocabulary to discuss the man on the street corner, the child we know with cancer, the news story of animals being mistreated, but we also shield them, because that is what parents do. We are trying to walk that line between sheltering and shocking.
Considering all of this – the need and want in the world – in the midst of my children arguing over who would get the biggest gifts was enough to make me want to make a change. I talked it over with Tom, and we agreed: Santa had to be reined in.
So, this year Santa brought three things: one was a book about a little girl named Beatrice who was given a goat, and as a result of the milk they could sell she got to go to school; the second was a small carved ornament for our tree in the shape of a goat; and the third was a letter from Santa explaining that he saw how happy and blessed they were, and knew they were special enough to want to share that joy with someone else. Maybe a little girl like Beatrice. He asked them to think all year long about who they would like to help next year, and to let him know when they saw him again.
And the girls ate it up. They talked about Beatrice all day, wondering if her goat had had more babies, and whether someone else in their village had gotten the goat we had bought, and if they could be goat friends. They wanted to write to Santa that day and tell him that next year they want to buy chickens, or maybe books for Beatrice instead.
Let me be clear: they still got way too many presents. We’re not depriving our children of toys. Gifts are wonderful – I love giving and getting them – but we are not entitled to them, and knowing the intent of love behind them makes them that much more special. We are giving them things because we knew they would enjoy them, not because they have earned them.
Time will tell whether this new version of Santa works. We hope to made Santa into a true spirit of giving, instead of the spirit of getting, and lay a foundation for gratitude and charity. I hope, in 15 years, we have a tree full of ornaments commemorating all the years we chose to give to others. I hope to keep the magic of Santa alive for a few more years, and as the girls outgrow the innocence of belief, they can still see the magic that exists in this new tradition.
I hope they don’t confuse Santa too much next year by asking for a cow.


